Born Free Foundation - Keep Wildlife in the Wild

Conservation Groups Thrown Out of International Elephant Debate

17 August 2011

Categories: Homepage News, Elephants Campaign News, Wildlife Trade News

In a shocking move that simply could not have been anticipated, some of the world’s leading wildlife conservation organisations were this morning summarily expelled from an international meeting on wildlife conservation in Geneva, Switzerland by a 7 to 6 vote. This move was initiated by the government of Kuwait on behalf of the Asian region and was supported by Botswana, Iran, Kuwait, Colombia, Costa Rica, Dominica and Norway. The organizations were removed from deliberations concerning elephant conservation, the international trade in ivory, and concerns regarding China’s increasing involvement in illegal ivory trade.  There is a fear that the decision may set a precedent and that such methods may be used to exclude NGOs and civil society from participating in debates on other issues such as rhino and tiger trade.

The measure was approved at the 61st Standing Committee meeting of CITES (Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora), despite the strong objections of the UK and Kenya. Democratic Republic of Congo, Bulgaria, Ukraine, United States of America and Australia also voted against the action in an effort to support transparency and public participation.  A simple majority in favour meant that the Species Survival Network (SSN),  Born Free Foundation, International Fund for Animal Welfare, Humane Society International, Environmental Investigation Agency, Elephant Family, World Wildlife Fund, and numerous others, organisations with decades of experience working on the frontline of wildlife conservation and representing tens of millions of members of the public from around the world, are now sitting in the lobby of the CIGC (Centre International de Conférences Genève) unable to assist and participate in debates on which the future of wild elephants may depend.

Speaking on behalf of the SSN, its President, Will Travers said “I am almost lost for words.  This is a terrible precedent and jeopardises the effective conservation of not only elephants but potentially many other species if we are prevented from participating in other debates.  The SSN, together with the American delegation nearly a decade ago successfully championed the participation of civil society representatives in Standing Committee meetings which, until this morning have been as open and transparent as possible, in line with UN principles.  That achievement, on behalf of the citizens of the world, is now in jeopardy.  Clearly, there is a co-ordinated initiative by some Parties to stifle open debate.  This simply must not be allowed to happen.”

Conservation organisations of all persuasions have played an active and positive role in helping CITES achieve meaningful and positive results for species that are or may be threatened by international trade.  In addition, thanks to the generosity of the general public, they contribute tens of millions of dollars each year to conservation efforts in some of the world’s most vulnerable places.  

Travers concluded, “This is a bleak day for principles that we all should hold dear - the principles of openness, transparency, accountability and responsibility.  It is imperative that CITES, a Treaty to which more than 175 countries subscribe, addresses this matter as a high priority and ensures and enshrines the participation of individuals, organisations and experts who have only one thing in common, their desire to ensure the long-term, sustainable survival of life on earth.”

Stay in touch with events in Geneva on Will's CITES blog


After the shock of an early morning vote at the CITES Standing Committee meeting in Geneva, Switzerland, which led to the exclusion of some of the world's leading wildlife conservation non-governmental organisations including the Species Survival Network, Born Free Foundation, Worldwide Fund for Nature, International Fund for Animal Welfare, Humane Society International, Environmental Investigation Agency, Elephant Family, and numerous others, from the debate on elephant poaching and the impact of the international illegal trade in ivory, a second vote at the start of the afternoon session reversed the previous decision and the Born Free Foundation, SSN and others are back in the room.

"Common sense has prevailed!" stated Will Travers, President of the Species Survival Network. "The previous expulsion of NGOs - the representatives of civil society and tens of millions of members of the public - was a major error of judgement. It cast a shadow over the work of the Convention and, had it persisted, would have diminished its ability to bring real conservation benefits to a range of threatened species."

The exact details of how this more enlightened second vote came about are unclear" continued Travers, "but the Standing Committee has gone some considerable way to restoring its reputation for progressive inclusivity to the lasting benefit of species that are or may be threatened by international trade."

Born Free Foundation
Broadlands Business Campus, Langhurstwood Road
, Horsham, RH12 4QP, UK - Charity Reg. No. 1070906

Share | |